More religious tolerance

Stuff we should click on.  Be sure to state Not Work Safe, if applicable.  KTHX.
Post Reply
Leisher
Site Admin
Posts: 70451
Joined: Thu May 20, 2004 9:17 pm
Contact:

Post by Leisher »

The French hate Muslims.

Muslims hate Christians.

I would never disagree that religion has done some people a lot of good in their lives. It's given folks a sense of morality, focus, etc. (Whether or not they could have gotten that from another source is another debate.)

However, you'd have a hard time convincing me that the overall effect of religion on the world has been anything other than negative.
"Happy slaves are the worst enemies of freedom." - Marie Von Ebner
"It was always the women, and above all the young ones, who were the most bigoted adherents of the Party, the swallowers of slogans, the amateur spies..." - Orwell
TPRJones
Posts: 13418
Joined: Fri May 21, 2004 2:05 pm
Location: Houston
Contact:

Post by TPRJones »

Leisher wrote:It's given folks a sense of morality...
I strongly disagree with this statement. Any "morals" derived from purely external sources and based in a fear of punishment is not a moral code at all.

The only valid moral codes are ones that the individual arrives at upon reflection on the nature of the universe and their own personal values of right and wrong. It has to come from a desire to do the "right" thing simply because it is the right thing, not because they are afraid their imaginary big daddy in the sky will spank them if they don't.
"ATTENTION: Customers browsing porn must hold magazines with both hands at all times!"
Leisher
Site Admin
Posts: 70451
Joined: Thu May 20, 2004 9:17 pm
Contact:

Post by Leisher »

(Whether or not they could have gotten that from another source is another debate.)


Yes, I'm quoting myself. I didn't want to debate this here because we've debated this topic previously, and recently. Plus, I think there's a larger topic on the effect religion has truly had on the human species.

However, since you're pushing the issue... :)

Any "morals" derived from purely external sources and based in a fear of punishment is not a moral code at all.


No disagreement on that statement, except your conclusion that I said religion (or "purely external sources") solely make up one's morals. External influences will always have an influence on one's moral compass, but I didn't mean to imply that it'd be the only one...if that's what you took away from my statement. Friends, family, society, education, entertainment, etc. all help form that moral compass. The most important factor, however, is how the person's brain is hardwired, IMHO.

The only valid moral codes are ones that the individual arrives at upon reflection on the nature of the universe and their own personal values of right and wrong.


See, you agree. One cannot create a moral compass without first creating values. Those values aren't created completely internally. One's religion, or spiritual beliefs, will affect those values and that moral compass.

It has to come from a desire to do the "right" thing simply because it is the right thing, not because they are afraid their imaginary big daddy in the sky will spank them if they don't.


We covered the "fear" thing, but this gives me an interesting thought. I wonder what the numbers are between murderers who believed in a higher power, and murderers who don't? Not only would the numbers be important, but so would the types of murder they committed. Do religious murderers commit murder out of passion (unplanned murders)? Do non-religious people commit murders for profit?
"Happy slaves are the worst enemies of freedom." - Marie Von Ebner
"It was always the women, and above all the young ones, who were the most bigoted adherents of the Party, the swallowers of slogans, the amateur spies..." - Orwell
TPRJones
Posts: 13418
Joined: Fri May 21, 2004 2:05 pm
Location: Houston
Contact:

Post by TPRJones »

I think we're on roughly the same page, I guess. Although I may be stronger in my stance that it is absolutely impossible for a religion to "give folks a sense of morality."
"ATTENTION: Customers browsing porn must hold magazines with both hands at all times!"
Leisher
Site Admin
Posts: 70451
Joined: Thu May 20, 2004 9:17 pm
Contact:

Post by Leisher »

Agreed.

I don't think it's impossible for religion to help someone build a proper moral compass, but as you said, it can't be the only source for that compass, and the religion must be taught properly.

As an example, if you claim your religion is all about peace and tolerance, you can't fly airplanes into skyscrapers to kill innocent civilians in the name of that religion.
"Happy slaves are the worst enemies of freedom." - Marie Von Ebner
"It was always the women, and above all the young ones, who were the most bigoted adherents of the Party, the swallowers of slogans, the amateur spies..." - Orwell
Malcolm
Posts: 32040
Joined: Fri May 21, 2004 1:04 pm
Location: Minneapolis

Post by Malcolm »

The most important factor, however, is how the person's brain is hardwired, IMHO.

Maybe. Some brains are hardwired to absorb & believe damn near anything anyone else tells them.

Do religious murderers commit murder out of passion (unplanned murders)? Do non-religious people commit murders for profit?

Assuming you could ever confirm someone truly believes in or denies a faith, that would very much depend upon the effect religion has upon the individual. For some, it's just another excuse to treat others shittily & rationalize it by claiming they're ultimately "saving" them & making their life (& perhaps afterlife) better. For others, it's an excuse to surrender any notion of independence, uniqueness, individualism, or personal responsibility, becoming pathetic puppets of human beings. I'd wager most folk fall somewhere in between those two extremes.
Diogenes of Sinope: "It is not that I am mad, it is only that my head is different from yours."
Arnold Judas Rimmer, BSC, SSC: "Better dead than smeg."
Malcolm
Posts: 32040
Joined: Fri May 21, 2004 1:04 pm
Location: Minneapolis

Post by Malcolm »

Leisher wrote:As an example, if you claim your religion is all about peace and tolerance, you can't fly airplanes into skyscrapers to kill innocent civilians in the name of that religion.
Sure you can, you just have to add some asterisks after "peace" and "tolerance."
Diogenes of Sinope: "It is not that I am mad, it is only that my head is different from yours."
Arnold Judas Rimmer, BSC, SSC: "Better dead than smeg."
Vince
Posts: 8624
Joined: Thu May 20, 2004 10:00 pm
Location: In bed with your mom

Post by Vince »

Leisher wrote:The French hate Muslims.

Muslims hate Christians.

I would never disagree that religion has done some people a lot of good in their lives. It's given folks a sense of morality, focus, etc. (Whether or not they could have gotten that from another source is another debate.)

However, you'd have a hard time convincing me that the overall effect of religion on the world has been anything other than negative.
Government has a worse track record than religion. And I'd argue that it was the politics of religion (not religion itself) that caused overall negative effect.

The simple act of practicing most religions generally doesn't cause bad things to happen.
"... and then I was forced to walk the Trail of Tears." - Elizabeth Warren
Malcolm
Posts: 32040
Joined: Fri May 21, 2004 1:04 pm
Location: Minneapolis

Post by Malcolm »

Vince wrote:The simple act of practicing most religions generally doesn't cause bad things to happen.
Unless "practicing" includes "forcibly convert everyone else." Soon as you think you got a supreme being or two in your corner, all kinds of weird thoughts start seeming justifiable.
Diogenes of Sinope: "It is not that I am mad, it is only that my head is different from yours."
Arnold Judas Rimmer, BSC, SSC: "Better dead than smeg."
Leisher
Site Admin
Posts: 70451
Joined: Thu May 20, 2004 9:17 pm
Contact:

Post by Leisher »

The simple act of practicing most religions generally doesn't cause bad things to happen.


Lots of Catholics in third world countries where people are starving and VDs are thriving refuse to wear condoms because they're practicing their religion.
"Happy slaves are the worst enemies of freedom." - Marie Von Ebner
"It was always the women, and above all the young ones, who were the most bigoted adherents of the Party, the swallowers of slogans, the amateur spies..." - Orwell
GORDON
Site Admin
Posts: 56735
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 10:43 pm
Location: DTManistan
Contact:

Post by GORDON »

Leisher wrote:
The simple act of practicing most religions generally doesn't cause bad things to happen.
Lots of Catholics in third world countries where people are starving and VDs are thriving refuse to wear condoms because they're practicing their religion.
Actually, minor point: If they were practicing their religion they wouldn't be screwing unless they were married. Fewer babies, no VD.
"Be bold, and mighty forces will come to your aid."
Malcolm
Posts: 32040
Joined: Fri May 21, 2004 1:04 pm
Location: Minneapolis

Post by Malcolm »

GORDON wrote:
Leisher wrote:
The simple act of practicing most religions generally doesn't cause bad things to happen.
Lots of Catholics in third world countries where people are starving and VDs are thriving refuse to wear condoms because they're practicing their religion.
Actually, minor point: If they were practicing their religion they wouldn't be screwing unless they were married. Fewer babies, no VD.
Even in developing countries, it's in your interests to have as many children as possible, even if monogamy is observed. Chances are increased that one of your kids amounts to something & pays your way for the rest of your life.

& it's amazing how quickly religion gets put aside when pussy is available.
Diogenes of Sinope: "It is not that I am mad, it is only that my head is different from yours."
Arnold Judas Rimmer, BSC, SSC: "Better dead than smeg."
GORDON
Site Admin
Posts: 56735
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 10:43 pm
Location: DTManistan
Contact:

Post by GORDON »

One man can have 1000 women pregnant at a time, and give all of them AIDS, contributing to the problem. But not if he is monogamous.
"Be bold, and mighty forces will come to your aid."
Vince
Posts: 8624
Joined: Thu May 20, 2004 10:00 pm
Location: In bed with your mom

Post by Vince »

GORDON wrote:
Leisher wrote:
The simple act of practicing most religions generally doesn't cause bad things to happen.
Lots of Catholics in third world countries where people are starving and VDs are thriving refuse to wear condoms because they're practicing their religion.
Actually, minor point: If they were practicing their religion they wouldn't be screwing unless they were married. Fewer babies, no VD.
Valid point.
"... and then I was forced to walk the Trail of Tears." - Elizabeth Warren
Leisher
Site Admin
Posts: 70451
Joined: Thu May 20, 2004 9:17 pm
Contact:

Post by Leisher »

The point might stop the spread of VDs, but not pregnancies.
"Happy slaves are the worst enemies of freedom." - Marie Von Ebner
"It was always the women, and above all the young ones, who were the most bigoted adherents of the Party, the swallowers of slogans, the amateur spies..." - Orwell
GORDON
Site Admin
Posts: 56735
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 10:43 pm
Location: DTManistan
Contact:

Post by GORDON »

No VD would exist anywhere if people waiting until they were married to have sex, and were monogamous.

Just saying.
"Be bold, and mighty forces will come to your aid."
Leisher
Site Admin
Posts: 70451
Joined: Thu May 20, 2004 9:17 pm
Contact:

Post by Leisher »

No argument there.

Although, not all religions bar pre-marital sex or more than one wife.
"Happy slaves are the worst enemies of freedom." - Marie Von Ebner
"It was always the women, and above all the young ones, who were the most bigoted adherents of the Party, the swallowers of slogans, the amateur spies..." - Orwell
GORDON
Site Admin
Posts: 56735
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 10:43 pm
Location: DTManistan
Contact:

Post by GORDON »

Honestly I could never get behind those rules. My sperm is just too in demand by hot chicks.
"Be bold, and mighty forces will come to your aid."
Post Reply