After the prequels and Lucas' doctoring of the original trilogy, not to mention the Star Trek reboot...I've got to go with Trek.
Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2011 2:28 pm
by TPRJones
Star Trek has a much richer cannon and a relatively realistic treatment of politics and sociology in it's structure of fake history.
Star Wars has Han Solo, and ... well, that's about it, really. Wookies are kind of cool, too, I guess.
Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2011 2:35 pm
by TheCatt
If we go back in time, say, before TNG, I think Star Wars wins, hands down. Star Trek tv show was good, not great. The movies were boring, imho.
The ST reboot, the expansion of the universe from TNG, etc, and the abysmal failure of the 2nd SW trilogy give it to ST.
Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2011 10:57 pm
by WSGrundy
Some parts of Star Wars suck but everything about Star Trek(besides Q) sucks.
Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2011 11:13 pm
by GORDON
WSGrundy wrote:Some parts of Star Wars suck but everything about Star Trek(besides Q) sucks.
All Good Things
Best of Both Worlds
The One Where He Gets the Flute
"THERE ARE FOUR LIGHTS"
Balance of Terror
KHAAAAAAAAAAN
"Target that Explosion and FIRE."
Posted: Fri Nov 18, 2011 10:55 am
by Leisher
Star Wars
SW: Ep1 - Jar Jar & that stupid kid
SW: Ep2 - More Jar Jar & Hayden Christianson
SW: Ep3 - Hayden Christianson & the "Nooooo"
SW: Ep4 - Han no longer shot first
SW: Ep5 - Best SW movie ever despite the incest
SW: Ep6 - Muppets
Star Trek
ST:TOS - Better than you remember.
ST:TNG - Best SciFi series ever.
ST:DS9 - Decent
ST:V - Meh
ST:E - Meh
ST: Original movie - Sucked
STII - Star Trek's "Empire"
STIII - Sucked
STIV - Hilarious in a good way
STV - Sucked
STVI - Good
STVII, VIII, IX, X - All decent
ST: The new one - Fantastic